The rub on sports creams

Submit your own questions to Dr. Prescott

Adam’s Training Journal

The other day, after a long run, I felt some tightness and pain in the back of my right knee. After a bit of internet sleuthing, I determined that the culprit was the iliotibial band (ITB), a common injury site for pavement pounders like me.

Dr. Wikipedia prescribed RICE—rest, ice, compression and elevation. I chose my own variation, which involved ice, stretching, running on soft surfaces and otherwise keeping time on my feet to a minimum. Fortunately for me, the treatment regimen seems to have worked, as I’m once again running pain-free.

But in the good, old days, when I was younger and faster, my treatment regimen undoubtedly would have consisted of another element: Bengay.

Like many young athletes, I imagined the surest way to loosen up was a healthy dose of this cream (or its cousin Icy Hot). So before every track meet, you could find me—and dozens of my teammates—anointing our legs with the stuff. Even today I cannot set foot in a locker room without it immediately conjuring the medicinal smell of days gone by.

I’ve long since left this pre-run ritual behind. I mean, who wants to smell like a medicine cabinet? But as my muscles have grown older and tighter, I’ve begun to wonder whether this aromatic practice might be worth reviving.

Dr. Prescott Prescribes

Last year, Americans spent more than $200 million on topical analgesics, or pain creams. Indeed, it’s a market that has existed in the U.S. since before the 20^th century. So you’d think that there might be some good evidence that they work.

You, however, would be wrong.

From a physiological standpoint, there’s little benefit that occurs in the tissue when you apply a topical cream. And research on the subject has been minimal and inconclusive.

Although many swear by these creams, they are most likely benefiting from the placebo effect, which can cause people to feel therapeutic effects from an inert medication simply because they have been told it works.

Also, these products contain chemicals that cause a warming or cooling effect on the skin, a sensation that can temporarily “crowd out” pain signals sent by injured or sore muscles. Yet this does nothing to alleviate the underlying cause of the pain.

Even doctors have Achilles heels

Submit your own questions to Dr. Prescott

Dr. Prescott’s Journal

I have a friend—let’s call him Steve—who’s suffered a running injury. Only problem is, Steve isn’t a runner.

In fact, he’s assiduously avoided running since those wind sprints he detested during his Vietnam-era high school football practices. But now it seems even the relatively minor bouncing of Pilates and some overly ambitious stretching has proven too much for my—I mean his—Achilles tendon.

Okay, you found me out. Apparently, two-plus years of dispensing medical wisdom in this column hasn’t rendered me immune to training injuries.

My Achilles, the tendon that connects my calf to my heel, is killing me. In fact, not long ago, the pain was so great that I had to resort to using a cane.

Unlike some people, I don’t have any aspirations to run a marathon. Or, frankly, ever to run again. But I would like to be able to walk and do Pilates again without pain.

What do you recommend?

Adam Prescribes

I may not be a doctor, but I am a runner. And like so many other runners, I’ve had to battle an Achilles injury.

The Achilles (named for the sole point of vulnerability on the otherwise immortal Greek hero) is the largest and strongest tendon in the body. But because activities like running—and Pilates—involve repeatedly applying large amounts of force to the tendon, members of the sweat set commonly suffer Achilles injuries.

So, dear patient, for openers, I prescribe rest. That means as little weight-bearing activity as possible. No Pilates. Keep walking to a minimum. And while that cane may not make you look young and spry, it will help your heal your Achilles heel (sorry).

You’ll also want to ice the tendon as often as possible to reduce swelling. If non-steroid anti-inflammatories like ibuprofen agree with you, those are also a great way to reduce tendon pain and inflammation.

If this course of treatment doesn’t prove effective, see a physician. (Not yourself, of course.) In particularly severe cases, the injury might require a steroid injection.

You know, I’ve enjoyed this rare opportunity to play doctor to your patient. But with the Oklahoma City Marathon coming up Sunday, I suspect I’ll be back on the examining table in no time.